Member No. 358 · 56 posts · joined 21-October 05 · Members
There's more to that (IMG

tyle_emoticons/default/tongue.gif) (A Long read, but a kinda of brief explanation)
Every empire starts as a beacon of hope and an example for each other country right. US was like that, Rome was like that, Persian was like that, Greek empire was like that and Egyptian empire was like that also. Each of them has contributed many things to the world's history. But every empire risen, every empire fallen. One thing always tends to when an empire falls, their leaders doesn't look history very throughly. My point his, they keep repeating the past mistakes over and over. "Ppl who doesn't know the history, tend to do the same errors all over again" Another example of this, when the Rome empire became so corrupt that Neron burned the city himself and blame the Christians for it and started to persecuted them. Are they doing the same, figuratively speaking?(quoting some points of STUFF's post). The world is going one step foward and three steps backward. Advancing on many things and going way back and lose the belief. Money is becoming the new cultural standard and consumerism as a religion.
As Tynvar and Crazybeans mentioned the Puertorrican issue if becoming state or independent, is a little complex situation.
PR was taken in 1898 by the US, during the Hispanoamerican War, from Spain as "War goods" or a part of a treaty(can't remember the exact name, I think is Paris or Versalles (IMG

tyle_emoticons/default/huh.gif) )From this point on, the political discussion of Puerto Rico becoming state or a republic, started. So anyway, we had military governors until the 1948, that's when the first governor wasn't a military man, but also a Puertorrican, but was appointed by the President, . But in 1952, they signed the 600 Law, which is "Federal Political and Economical Relations between Puerto Rico and United States of America" and thus the Puertorrican constitution came, called "Estado Libre Asociado" (Commonwealth) and the first governor elected by the ppl came to office. This turnmoil goes on and on until the first State/Indepence Referedum came(circa 1970-1980). The polls was leave Puerto Rico as is, a commonwealth. In this Commonwealth, Puerto Rico has political representation called "Residential Comissioner (Comisionado Residente) or a counsel in the Congress, but can't vote, just speak. Also in international competition, PR get a own representation. In a part, PR is treated as country, and other as a colony. The other referendum came around 1998, but this time was 5 options, two were commonwealth kinda of options, statehood, independence and none of the above. None of above option won. That means, they don't want independence or either statehood, like leave it as is as the first one.
Going around explaining those options, there's 3 political parties (an very brief explanation)
Partido Popular Democr�tico (Democratic Popular Party): Founded in 1952, their point of view is like sort of "best of two worlds", keeping a commonwealth. This politcal party is sort of governing this island as we speak, but the sort of...part gonna be explained later.
Partido Nuevo Progresista (New Progress Party) : Founded in 1968 and won their first election in that year. This party represent the Statehood option to PR. This political party won the last elections the Senate and House of Representative,
Partido Independentista Puertorrique�o (Puertorrican Independce Party) Founded in 1963, this one represent the Independence of Puerto Rico, but they are searchin other things. In this particular case, worth mention the other Independence group, which is divided in much party, as Socialists, Congresso Hostosiano Puertorrique�o, Nationalists and many others, since the PIP is corrupted and they went away from their objective as the other political parties.
Why Puerto Rico and US doesn't solve the status quo problem that is fudging up for century now?
There's a couple of answer to that. First, US doesn't want it to do that, even thought they seem the contrary, because, PR is one of their top buyers of their products in the world. PR sends more money to the US than the US send to us. That's one of that reasons. Also, they do whatever they want in PR, since it's a colony or a "commonwealth"
As explaining why the PR ppl doesn't want the independence or the statehood. A couple of factors to make this,
1)The psychological behavior of the Puertorrican is quite complex. Most them Puertorricans are a bit lazy, or they want everything without working hard. A wrong way of thinking and living. There's many jobs there, but doesn't want to work, since they think "we get money easier by welfare and many programs and not lifting a finger for working". The other part is the fear imposed by the political parties through the media and still alive some how the "Cold War Era" way of thinking, if PR get independent, they become commies and lose all of the welfare programs. But if they go statehood, they think losing their representation and many benefits as they get right as we speak. This particular way of thinking is coming from the Spanish Era. An example of Alejandro O'Reilly in his essay "El Pa�s de Cuatro Pisos", saying "El Puertorrique�o es vago, ya que el mismo Imperio no le da las herramientas para construir su propio lugar(The Puertorrican person is lazy since, the Empire doesn't provide them with tools for build their own place) " Consecuently, this type of thing creates apathy, then egocentrism for many of the good and bad situations in PR. Also the, Puertorrican is kinda of violent towards the other, but when it comes to the goverment violatinting his rights, they kneel and become week, like a crybaby.
2)Dirty politicians and other ppl who are in power or gets the funds by creating political parties(yes they do get their funds by the goverment) They don't want statehood, coz they lose some benefits and federal funding. The corruption on the goverment is so deep that, take a bit, it crumbles the entire system. But there's some ppl who wants to work for the peeps, like almost all countries of the world.
3)The constant turmoil of the political parties about governing Puerto Rico. They tend to get angry and all the attention on trivial things as a smoke screen and passing behind scenes some laws which is pretty harmful to the general public, specially for the working class.
Many of the Puertorrican wants Statehood, but they doesn't work for it, since their leaders are so corrupt.
Many of the Puertorrican people wants a Asociated Republic or a Commonwealth(more like Australia, Canada and other countries. this a better way that using CW as a smoke screen name), but their leaders some are corrupt or scared in their underpants.
Many of the Puertorrican people wants the Independence, but they are so corrupt, that they doesn't care crap about their object and divide this group into smaller groups and smashing them to the ground, since they are becoming a threat to their leaders.
There's was some very good research about "What if Puerto Rico is indepedent" and some of them says, it can go better without being a commonwealth nor state.
I have to agree with White Knight, it's a total nonsense about not changing the number of stars in the flag. It can change the flag, but since PR is a colony. Thinking of why they don't the same thing has the State of Tennesee did. They declared independent and they went to Congress with a document saying they want the Statehood. Wondering why? And besides, there's some document that was going down to the Congress about the status quo of Puerto Rico. Also other thing, Washington D.C., the federal capital, wants to be state 51. In that case, PR would be 52.
But enough of the Puerto Rico's situation. Focusing now on the main point.
There's some many options about an empire goes down. Dividing like the Roman Empire(West and East, later Ottoman Empire), disappear or disbanding as the Mayan Empire, or each State claiming their independence, war(hopefully not), bad economical situation (hopefully not), etc...
My Opinnion:
"If a person, country, etc doesn't know it's history, they are tending to do the same mistakes of the past. That's why is history for". Every human has the indeniable, indestructibule right to be free, so does the country where the human lives. Puerto Rico can be a Country or Republic, a good Commonwealth or even Statehood as long the people work for it and not steal money from this ideal, object, etc.
Apologies for the long post (IMG

tyle_emoticons/default/tongue.gif), I hope it's explain a tid bit (IMG

tyle_emoticons/default/tongue.gif)